I “asked” Bing AI about those who see the traditional family as “a social structure of oppression” and who suggest that the dissolution of the traditional family might or would be a good thing for the world. I asked about those who say boys and girls, men and women, are becoming obsolete categories making room for new visions for humanity and perhaps a new species of “persons”. I have eliminated the redundant parts of my seeking clarifications to my questions.

Most of us understand I think that it is important to distinguish homosexual persons from the elite ideological movements which, flouting the objective Natural Law, serve as the vehicle for the totalitarian  transformation of language, law, history, culture, institutions and nations in the West and beyond. Only the latter, is to be considered per se repugnant to Christianity. God alone will judge persons. — SH

Bing: There are many reasons why families may face challenges and difficulties. Some recent articles suggest that polarized politics and the COVID-19 pandemic have contributed to family estrangement and division¹³. Family estrangement is a situation in which someone intentionally cuts off all communication with one or more relatives for the long-term¹. It’s a complex issue that can have many underlying causes and can impact individuals and families in different ways.

It’s important to note that every family is unique and may face different challenges. If you or someone you know is experiencing difficulties within their family, it may be helpful to seek support from a qualified therapist or counselor.

Bing AI continues,

There are different perspectives on the meaning and importance of gender in society and culture. Some people argue that gender is a social construct that limits the expression and potential of individuals, and that we should move towards a world without gender1. Others believe that gender is a natural and essential aspect of human identity and diversity, and that we should celebrate and respect the differences between men and women2. There are also many scientific studies that explore the psychological, biological, and behavioral differences between men and women, but they often find that these differences are not absolute or consistent, and that most humans are a mixture of both female-typical and male-typical characteristics.

Therefore, it may not be accurate or helpful to think of boys and girls, men and women, as obsolete categories, but rather as fluid and dynamic ones that can vary across time, place, and context. What do you think?

Me: When you speak of boys girls men and women as fluid and dynamic categories that can vary across time place and context are you suggesting that these categories— boys girls men and women— could evolve into a new kind of species into the future?

Bing AI

No, I’m not suggesting that. I’m saying that the way we understand and define gender can change depending on the historical, cultural, and personal factors that influence our perception and expression of it.

Gender is not a fixed or static trait that determines who we are or what we can do. It is a complex and dynamic aspect of our identity and diversity that can evolve over time. Does that make sense?

Me: Again, to be more precise because it sounds as you are suggesting it: when you say “gender is “not a fixed or static trait that determines who we are or what we can do it’s a complex and dynamic aspect of our identity and diversity that can evolve over time” does that mean this evolution will be subjective and personal, unique to specific individuals or groups of individuals, or, again, are you saying that the entire species could theoretically evolve into new species beyond the traditional gender limits of homo sapiens.

Bing AI

Some human persons can change their gender expression or gender identity, or both, through various means. Some may change their name, pronouns, clothing, hairstyle, or voice to match their gender identity. Some may also seek medical interventions, such as hormone therapy or surgery, to align their body with their gender identity¹²³. These are some of the ways that human persons can transition from one gender to another, or to a nonbinary gender. However, not all human persons who identify with a different gender than the one they were assigned at birth want or need to change their gender expression or undergo medical treatment. Each person’s journey of gender identity is unique.

It means that gender is not something that we are born with and cannot change. It is something that we develop and express through our interactions with ourselves, others, and the world. It is something that can vary depending on our personal feelings, experiences, and contexts. It is something that can reflect and celebrate our unique identities and diversities.

Some human persons may change their names, pronouns, clothing, hairstyle, or voice to match their gender identity. For example, a person who was assigned female at birth but identifies as male may change their name from Jessica to James, use he/him pronouns, wear more masculine clothes, cut their hair short, or deepen their voice. These are some of the ways that a person can change their gender expression to match their gender identity. Do you understand? 

It seems to be that the awareness and visibility of gender fluidity have increased in recent decades, especially among younger generations¹². However, that does not mean that gender fluidity is a new phenomenon or a trend. There is evidence of gender diversity and fluidity in many cultures and historical periods³. Gender fluidity is not something that people choose or adopt, but rather something that they experience and express as part of their identity and diversity.

On Ubiquitous Pornography, Family and Gender Confusion

Bing AI: You are concerned about the impact of pornography on the family and the future of humanity. You have read that some radical persons, such as feminists and socialists, want to destroy the family because they see it as a unit of oppression. In this context, a human might say that this is a very controversial and complex topic, and that there are different perspectives and arguments on both sides. Some people might argue that the family is not a natural or universal institution, but a historical and cultural construct that has changed over time⁴. They might also argue that the family is not always a source of love and support, but sometimes a site of violence and abuse. They might advocate for alternative forms of kinship and community that are more inclusive and diverse. What do you think of these arguments?

SH: Not much.

“Conversation” with Bing, 5/17/2023
(1) Family estrangement: Why adults are cutting off their parents. https://www.bbc.com/worklife/article/20211201-family-estrangement-why-adults-are-cutting-off-their-parents.
(2) The pandemic has destroyed friendships and divided families. https://www.cnn.com/2020/12/15/us/pandemic-rift-friendships-wellness-trnd/index.html.
(3) Families Have Been Torn Apart by Politics. What Happens to Them Now?. https://www.nytimes.com/2020/11/26/us/2020-election-family-conflict.html.

— The Nation: Want to Dismantle Capitalism? Abolish the Family